Over the years the Mill Theatre has been privileged to receive many awards for its shows, both plays and musicals, performed at the theatre itself or ‘on the road’ at drama festivals. Here are just some of those awards:
NODA Awards (East Area, District 2)
| 2024 – Rewired Creatives/writers – Kaye Vincent/Kaye Tompkins | Best Production Shield Best Musical |
| 2021/2022 – Once Upon a Christmas Song Director – Kathryn Rose / Musical Director – Kaye Tompkins | Best Production Shield Best Musical |
| 2021/2022 – Daisy Pulls It Off Director – Nicole Macdonald | Best Youth Production |
| 2020 – The Railway Children Director – Paul Wildman | Best Technical – for the appearance of The Train |
| 2018 – Cloud Director – Kaye Vincent | Best Technical – for the futuristic costumes |
| 2016 – Romeo and Juliet Director – Barry Thompson | Best Play |
| 2015 – Macbeth Director – Barry Thompson | Best Play |
| 2015 – Camelot Director – Christine Summerling | Best Technical – for excellent costumes and an atmospheric two-level set |
| 2015 – Miss Saigon School Edition Director – Paul Wildman | Best Production Shield Best Youth Production Best Young Performer – Jasmine Bayes (as Kim) |
| 2013 – Blood Brothers Director – Dan Robinson | Best Youth Production Best Young Performer – Antonia Testa (as Mrs. Johnstone) |
| 2013 – Glorious Director – Pat Gale | Best Play |
| 2012 – West Side Story Director – Paul Wildman | Best Youth Performer – Ayesha Reid (Anita) |
| 2011 – Ladies’ Day Director – Enid Cooper | Best Youth Performer – Louise Hoare |
| 2010 – Les Miserables – School Edition Director – Paul Wildman | Best Youth Performer – Simon Jackson (as Jean Valjean) |
| 2009 – Wyrd Sisters Director – Enid Cooper | Best Play |
| 2008 – The Importance Of Being Earnest Director – Enid Cooper | Best Play |
| 2008 – Aladdin Director – Enid Cooper | Best Pantomime |
| 2007 – Suddenly At Home Director – Enid Cooper | Best Play |
| 2005 – The Dresser Director – Susan Moore | Best Play |
| 2004 – Habeus Corpus Director – David Midlane | Best Play (runner-up) |
Drama Festival Awards
| 2008 – Three Tall Women | Felixstowe Drama Festival
Best Actress: Kim Vaughan |
| 2008 – Three Tall Women | Thurrock Drama Festival
Best Presentation Best Actress: Kim Vaughan Runner-up for Best Play |
| 2008 – Three Tall Women | Skegness Drama Festival
Best Play Best Director: David Midlane Best Actress: Susan Moore |
| 1994 – Confusions | Bedfordshire Drama Festival
Best Actress: Virginia Pope |
| 1993 – Blue Remembered Hills | Bedfordshire Drama Festival
Best Play Best Set Best Director: Maureen Leaske Best Actor: Peter Allen |
